Our Insurance Companies

Insurance Companies

Preferred First Insurance represents the following insurance companies

Click on a company to view contact information.

Claims

800-289-5255

Payments

800-677-0777


More info about AAA

Claims

866-814-5595

website

Payments

866-206-5851


More info about Accident Fund

Claims

800-282-9445

website

Payments

800-282-1446

website


More info about Allied

Claims

800-346-0346

website

Payments

800-346-0346

website


More info about Auto Owners

Claims

800-922-4050

website

Payments

800-922-4050

website


More info about Hagerty

Claims

800-243-5860

website

Payments

800-624-5578

website


More info about The Hartford

Claims

800-421-3535

website

Payments

888-891-0267

website


More info about Nationwide

Claims

800-274-4499

website

Payments

800-888-7764

website


More info about Progressive

Claims

800-332-3226

website

Payments

800-332-3226

website


More info about Safeco

Claims

800-766-1853

website

Payments

800-444-9950

website


More info about State Auto

Claims

800-252-4633

website

Payments

877-878-2468

website


More info about Travelers